This is what happens when you are bored at 2am and you can't sleep. I began to wonder one night "Who exactly ARE the best players of this past decade?" and I thought of ways to measure it. There's VORP but while VORP is great, you cannot help but wonder if there's other ways as well. You wanna make it even handed after all. So then I got to work looking for stats. So I looked up 3 different stats -- at least for this pitcher version I used SNLVAR (Support Neutral Lineup-Adjusted Valued Above Replacement), VORP (Value Over Replacement Player), and WPA (Win Probability Added). So each year, I tallied the top 10, came up with a points system and through that ranked the top 10 accordingly. I did this for all 10 years and then I gathered those results and tallied all the pointage and came up with a Top 10. I had some ties but I used certain sort of head-to-head rankings in a way as in (did X outrank Y more than once?) and then did so accordingly. This caused one pitcher to be pushed out of the top 10...the other only because of number of years. Anybody from two seasons and up counted in this. May not be the best measure because 1/5 of the decade may not be enough to prove anything, but hey this is my list dammit.
So anyways I'll give you the information of the top 10 of each year and my definitive Top 10 accordingly.
( Number Crunching )So tallying this all together, this is how my Top 10 turned out --
OVERALL
1) Randy Johnson
2) Johan Santana
3) Pedro Martinez
4) Roy Halladay
5) Curt Schilling
6) Tim Lincecum
7) Chris Carpenter
8) Brandon Webb
9) Tim Hudson
10) Mike Mussina
Honorable Mentions
*Jason Schmidt
*Roy Oswalt
I was really torn on the Oswalt v. Mussina situation. I gave the edge to Mussina because his rankings overall were better than Oswalt's (Oswalt had a couple lower rankings with one high one while Mussina kinda had a happy medium)
Another fun fact was that 2000 was the easiest year to calculate bar none because the top 4 was the same across the three different systems. The Lincecum one is kinda sticking out like a sore thumb and I'm kinda torn concerning that one. But I'll let it stand for now.